How Does the Value of Old Cut Diamonds Compare to Modern Cut Diamonds?
Before we share our insights — gleaned from conversations with industry thought leaders — it is essential to remind our community that this is not intended as investment advice. At Choo Yilin, we have always championed the belief that jewellery should be cherished for its stories, heritage, and the deep love it symbolises. Rooted in our brand philosophy of celebrating life’s journey and moments of becoming, we encourage our pieces to be valued for their meaning and beauty, rather than as alternative investment vehicles.
The Choo Yilin Old Cut Diamond Ring No. IX
1.Rarity and Historical Significance
Old Mine Cut diamonds, which were crafted by hand during the Georgian (1714–1837), Victorian (1837–1901), and Edwardian (1901–1910) periods, are genuinely rare. In contrast to Modern Brilliant diamonds, which are produced in large quantities today, Old Mine Cuts are a finite resource. Their rarity and historical origins may add emotional and perceived value, which some believe could increase over time. Each stone holds a small piece of history, and their authenticity is increasingly appreciated by collectors.
2. Sustainability and Ethical Appeal
In today’s world, sustainability is more important than ever. Old Mine Cuts can be seen as inherently sustainable, as they are vintage stones that require no new mining or environmental impact, and they may avoid modern concerns around sourcing. As more consumers seek eco-conscious purchases, the charm of antique diamonds may continue to grow.
3. Distinctive, Romantic Aesthetic
Old Mine Cut diamonds are admired for their soft, romantic glow — often described as a “candlelit sparkle.” With high crowns, small tables, and chunky facets, they offer a unique sparkle. While Modern Brilliant Cuts are celebrated for their sharp brilliance, Old Mine Cuts have a character that resonates with those drawn to a more distinctive, vintage look.
4. Artisanal Craftsmanship
These diamonds are a testament to a bygone era of artisanal craftsmanship. Each Old Mine Cut was shaped by hand without modern technology, leading to subtle asymmetry that lend individuality and charm. No two stones are exactly alike, and this human touch — less evident in today’s machine-cut diamonds — can add immeasurable meaning for those who appreciate artistry.
5. Growing Demand for Vintage Jewellery
The demand for vintage and antique jewellery has grown as heritage craftsmanship gain popularity. Celebrities and designers have embraced vintage aesthetics, and this trend has renewed interest in Old Mine Cut diamonds. Because these stones are no longer produced, this increased demand may enhance their desirability for collectors.
6. Timeless Romance
Old Mine Cut diamonds evoke nostalgia and romance, often feeling as though they carry the stories of past generations. For those seeking deeper emotional connections to their jewellery, these diamonds offer a meaningful, timeless beauty that can make them especially sought after.
7. Price Stability and Long-Term Appreciation
Old Mine Cut diamonds may be less influenced by market fluctuations than Modern Brilliant diamonds. Their rarity and perceived historical significance are seen by some as offering a degree of price stability. Some collectors and enthusiasts view them as having long-term appreciation potential, in addition to their aesthetic and sentimental value.
It’s important to note that Old Mine Cuts may not suit every buyer. Their sparkle is softer, and some may prefer the sharp brilliance of modern cuts. However, for those who value artisanal craftsmanship, rich history, and individuality, Old Mine Cuts offer a meaningful and distinctive option.
Create Your bespoke Choo Yilin Old Cut Diamond piece
At Choo Yilin, we understand that each piece of jewellery tells a story that begins long before it reaches the wearer and will continue to be told for generations to come. Now, for the first time, we are thrilled to bring the same dedication and craftsmanship to Old Cut Diamonds, offering you the opportunity to customise your own Choo Yilin diamond heirloom.
As with our jade pieces, each Old Cut diamond piece will be a celebration of life’s milestones — whether it’s a once-in-a-lifetime engagement ring, a cherished anniversary piece, or a family heirloom to pass down through generations.
There are only twelve slots available. If you’d like to explore creating a bespoke piece, you may sign up here.
